Judge Rules Novig’s Sports Contracts Are Gambling, Not Financial Swaps

Key Points

  • Novig failed to persuade a federal judge that its sports contracts qualify as swaps exempt from state gambling regulation
  • Judge Colleen McMahon slammed the CFTC's legal positions and questioned its intervention in prediction market enforcement actions
  • The preliminary injunction denial adds to a fractured national landscape of conflicting court rulings over state vs. federal gaming authority

A federal judge has rejected an effort by prediction market operator Novig to insulate its sports contracts from New York’s gambling laws, finding that the products are essentially bets on sports and not financial derivatives protected by federal law.

Novig, prediction markets, sports betting, CFTC, New York gambling laws
Novig argues that its sports contracts are financial derivatives regulated by the CFTC, not conventional sports bets. Judge Colleen McMahon was unconvinced, pointing to the striking similarities between the platform’s offerings and those of traditional sportsbooks. (Image: Novig)

In a 35-page opinion issued Tuesday, U.S. District Judge Colleen McMahon denied Novig’s request for a preliminary injunction against New York Attorney General Letitia James and the state’s gaming regulators.

Novig had argued that the federal Commodity Exchange Act (CEA) preempts New York from enforcing its sports betting laws against the company.

The ruling leaves the state poised to pursue enforcement action against Novig, compelling the platform to either secure a New York gambling license or cease operations in the state. However, the decision does not immediately force Novig to shut down operations nationwide.

A Sports Bet by Another Name

Novig operates a peer-to-peer exchange where customers trade contracts on sports outcomes rather than placing bets against a traditional sportsbook. In June, the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) designated its parent company, Ludlow Exchange LLC, as a contract market.

Novig had argued that its contracts were “swaps” solely governed by the CFTC and therefore outside the reach of state gambling regulators.

McMahon disagreed. While sporting outcomes count as “events or contingencies” under the CEA, she wrote that they lacked the type of inherent financial or commercial consequences needed to make the contracts swaps.

McMahon noted that Novig’s contracts—including point spreads, player props, and parlays—are functionally indistinguishable from sports wagers offered on FanDuel and BetMGM. She cited one four-game NFL parlay offered on the platform that carried a payout exceeding 111 times the original stake.

“The Court is not required to disregard common sense—Novig’s sports event contracts are sports betting,” McMahon wrote.

The judge also noted that Novig had held a Colorado sports betting license before giving it up and transitioning to its federally-regulated exchange model.

Judge Targets CFTC

McMahon reserved her sharpest criticism for the CFTC, which has repeatedly attempted to draw a distinction between financially traded sports contracts and traditional sports betting.

She characterized the agency’s recent regulatory positions as contradictory and questioned whether it had attempted to improperly influence the ongoing litigation.

More pointedly, McMahon suggested that a separate CFTC order preventing a rival prediction platform from shutting down while facing legal action “smacks of a collusive effort” to manufacture a conflict with federal law.

She added that even if Novig’s contracts were legally categorized as swaps, federal commodities law would not automatically displace New York’s long-standing police power over gambling.

While the ruling is not the final verdict in Novig’s lawsuit, it adds to an increasingly complex and fractured landscape of court decisions surrounding prediction markets nationwide.

Philip Conneller
Philip Conneller Senior Reporter

In Philip Conneller’s eight years with Casino.org, he has covered the gaming industry from Las Vegas to Macau and everything in between. He currently focuses his coverage on gaming law, white-collar crime, global money laundering, tribal gaming, politics, and regulation.

Philip was the original features editor for poker’s Bluff Magazine and editor for Bluff Europe, which he helped launch. His writing has also been featured in ESPN, Forbes, Time Out, The Sun, and The Daily Star, as well as iGaming Business, eGaming Review, and numerous other industry news and tech websites.

His news stories for Casino.org/news have been linked by The Washington Post, The Daily Mail, People Magazine, and Jimmy Fallon's Tonight Show, among many others.

Philip once won $20,000 with 7-2 off-suit. He has been reprimanded for unwittingly playing Elton John’s piano on two separate occasions on both sides of the Atlantic.

He became a writer because he is a lousy pianist.

Philip lives outside London with his wife and children, where he spends his time agonizing about Arsenal FC.

Contact Philip at philip.conneller@casino.org.

Comments icon

Conversation (0)

+ Add a comment

Be the first to comment on this article.

Write a comment

Your email address will not be published.